top of page
Search

The Weight of “Should”: How One Little Word Can Affect Your Emotions, Anxiety, and Self-Esteem

Nov 9
4 min read

How often do you find yourself telling yourself you should be doing something? You should exercise more, be more patient with your kids, accomplish more, or somehow be doing a better job of managing everything life throws your way. The word “should” may seem harmless, but when it becomes a regular part of our self-talk, it can have a greater impact on our emotional well-being than we realize.


In cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), “should” statements are considered a type of cognitive distortion, meaning a pattern of thinking that can contribute to unhelpful emotions and behaviors. These thoughts create rigid expectations about how we, others, or our lives should be. When reality doesn't meet those expectations, we may experience guilt, shame, frustration, anxiety, or a sense that we simply aren't good enough.


Having goals and expectations can be motivating and healthy. The problem begins when those expectations turn into rigid rules that leave little room for life to happen. For example, telling yourself, “I'd like to exercise three times this week,” allows for flexibility. You recognize that life can get busy, you may feel tired, or unexpected responsibilities may come up. You can adjust your plans and try again. On the other hand, telling yourself, “I should be exercising every day,” creates a much different expectation.


Missing a workout may become more than simply missing a workout. You might begin telling yourself you're lazy, a failure, or not doing enough. Over time, these unrealistic expectations can create ongoing pressure and anxiety as you worry about what you haven't done, what you still need to accomplish, or whether you're doing enough.


“Should” statements can also turn an ordinary situation into a judgment about who we are. Imagine having a difficult day at work. You might initially think, “I should have handled that better.” That thought can quickly become, “I should be better at this,” and eventually, “Why can't I get anything right?” What started as one difficult interaction has now become a judgment about your abilities and even your self-worth. Our thoughts influence our emotions, and when we repeatedly tell ourselves we should be doing more, accomplishing more, or handling life better, we create a constant feeling that we're falling short. This can contribute to anxiety, self-doubt, and the feeling that we're never quite doing enough.


One way to begin changing this pattern is to recognize when you're using the word “should” and pause to consider what is behind the thought. Ask yourself whether this is a goal you genuinely want for yourself or an expectation you've absorbed from someone else. Is the expectation realistic? Would you speak to someone you love the same way? What are you making this mean about yourself if you don't accomplish it? These questions can help you recognize when an expectation has become a form of self-criticism rather than healthy motivation.


You can also begin practicing more flexible ways of talking to yourself. Instead of saying, “I should exercise,” try saying, “I would like to make time for movement because it helps me feel better.” Rather than telling yourself, “I should be able to handle this,” consider, “This is difficult, and it's okay to ask for help.” Instead of thinking, “I shouldn't feel this way,” try reminding yourself, “I don't like feeling this way, but my feelings are giving me information.” And when you catch yourself thinking, “I should be further along by now,” consider replacing it with, “I can acknowledge where I am while continuing to work toward where I want to be.”


The goal isn't to lower your standards, stop challenging yourself, or give up on your goals. It's about removing the judgment from the expectation. One of the most powerful shifts we can make is moving from “I should” to “I choose.” For example, “I should call my friend” becomes “I choose to reach out because this relationship is important to me.” “I should take better care of myself” becomes “I choose to prioritize my health because I deserve to feel well.” While “should” can feel like punishment or an obligation, “choose” creates a sense of ownership and control. The words may seem similar, but the emotional message behind them is very different.


There will always be things we could have done differently, goals we haven't reached, and days when we're less patient, productive, or motivated than we'd like to be. That doesn't mean we're failing. It means we're human. The next time you catch yourself thinking, “I should,” pause and ask yourself, “Is this an expectation, or am I using it to judge myself?” Sometimes, becoming kinder to ourselves doesn't mean giving up on our goals. It means changing the way we talk to ourselves while continuing to move forward. By letting go of rigid expectations, we can reduce some of the unnecessary pressure we place on ourselves, make room for flexibility, and approach life with greater self-compassion.


You don't have to earn your worth by perfectly meeting every expectation you've placed on yourself.

 
 
 

Comments


Book Now!

Kairos Constructive Counseling does not share any client data with third parties for marketing, promotional purposes, or any other purposes. Your personal information is kept confidential and is not disclosed to any outside organizations, except as required by law or with your explicit consent.

 

By providing a telephone number and submitting the form you are consenting to be contacted by SMS text message from Kairos Constructive Counseling. Message frequency may vary. Message & data rates may apply. If you receive a text, Reply STOP to opt-out of further messaging. Reply HELP for more information. See our Privacy Policy by clicking the link below. 

​

Privacy Policy

Thanks for submitting!

Kairos Constructive Counseling

PH: 920-212-3970

Fax: 920-349-7335

W7185 Hwy 49

Waupun, WI 53963

(Entrance on West side of building)

KLogo.png
bottom of page